The Barnes & Noble Review: “a gorgeous handful of interior illustrations by Terry Beatty constitute the delicious frosting on this quintessentially New York black-and-white cookie of a book.”
Blogcritics: "extremely satisfying for both comic and mystery fan-addicts"
Pulp Fiction Reviews: "truly a breath of fresh air." "wonderful spot illustrations provided by the super talented Terry Beatty; all done in the marvelous retro golden age style of art…add a really nice visual element to what is already a fun read."
Bill Crider's Pop Culture Magazine: "thoroughly entertaining…Besides the dandy storytelling here, there's the Glen Orbik cover, which replicates one of the more famous EC covers, plus a lot of illustrations by Terry Beatty in the good old EC style. Lots of bang for your buck here….Be on the lookout; you don't want to miss it."
Ed Gorman's Blog: "superior storytelling" "Beatty is among the very best illustrators of our time and his homage to the original EC drawings is magnificent."
The Geek Girl Project: "Max Allan Collins’ Seduction of the Innocent is a wonderful, fun, frothy mix of genres, with lots of in-jokes thrown in for fans of the aforementioned. It’s noir, pulp, and comic book, with a double-handful of alternate history thrown in for flavor. It’s a fast, exciting read, well worth carting along for moments-between or sitting down with for some self-indulgent reading."
The Celebrity Cafe: "punches with short, rib-cracking jabs until the final sequence that strikes with a hard right cross."
Book Reporter: "Few people alive today can tell a story better than Max Allan Collins. SEDUCTION OF THE INNOCENT is a great, page-turning read that is beautiful to look at and serves as another proud addition to the Hard Case Crime library."
pornokitsch: "The story is over the top, but fun, Mr. Collins loves his comics…and the whole book is permeated with a sense of, well, joy. Murderous, sexpot, hard-drinking, gun-totin' scandelous joy."
FEARnet: "Fantastic" "horror fans who only know Hard Case from its passing trip through Stephen King country with The Colorado Kid (and his upcoming novel, Joyland) are missing out on some exciting, gripping work by Collins"
The Fandom Post: A+ "Collins does a masterful job of paying homage to both Rex Stout and the comic industry in general."
Bookgasm: "Collins expertly and effectively re-creates the period and ambience of New York in the ’50s while presenting a classically hard-boiled whodunit murder mystery. The locations, fashions, pop-culture references and especially Jack’s narration are all dead-on accurate and evocative."
The Bookbag: "perfectly written, hitting all the right notes in terms of atmosphere, characterisation and plot and I loved it."
Not the Baseball Pitcher: "Not to be missed."
Crime Time: "an ingenious roman à clef…great fun, whether or not you are an aficionado of the comics of that era."
Cult Geek: "This is edge of your seat drama on a big scale, bringing back the “who done it” genre with serious clout behind it."
Somebody Dies: "as a slice of history or simply as a golden-age mystery…[Seduction of the Innocent is] fun either way."
ComicMix: "I’d like to say it is one of the best books ever written, but that’s a stupid concept. However, I can say it is one of the most fun books I’ve ever read."
MysteryPeople: "A must read for crime and comic fans alike."
MysteryPeople (2): "Seduction of the Innocent is classic Collins. It’s punchy, funny, and fast-paced. It’s the kind of book you can’t help but finish in one sitting, and that’s what makes it so satisfying."
nerds of a feather: "Seduction of the Innocent is marked by careful plotting, sharp dialog, and a mastery of genre conventions…"
Comichype: "phenomenally entertaining"
Books and Writers: "…everything I like in one handsome little package: Great pulp Hard Case Crime cover?- CHECK. Great narrative by one of my favourite US authors, Max Allan Collins? – CHECK. A crime fiction meets the world of comic books theme (including some rather nice internal illustrations between chapters)? – CHECK, CHECK, CHECK."
Bristol Comics Corner: "Seduction of the Innocent is comics-meet-crime-noir against the glorious (and grim) city backdrop, with added sex appeal. It’s this type of tale that publisher, Hard Case Crime, was born to tell….Seduction of the Innocent is just good fun."
Geek Hard: "[Seduction of the Innocent is] a fast read that’s jam-packed with tons of enjoyment. If you like good guys, bad guys, femme fatales and funny books, this one’s for you."
Spinetingler: "An insightful historical mystery infused with the page-turning thrust of pulp, a fan’s fond affection for vintage comics, and an insider’s perspective on the industry as only a comic-creator would know, Seduction of the Innocent is a richly crafted novel that fascinates and entertains on multiple levels, and marvelously displays the many different sides and diverse talents of its creator, Max Allan Collins."
The American Culture: "Overall, Seduction of the Innocent is a delightful read. It’s got classic detection, and it’s got a great hardboiled narrator. There is terrific art throughout, likable characters, and an interesting plot. In all, I really enjoyed this book. There’s plenty to sink your teeth into, and the book makes for a quick read; I highly recommend it."
Trash Mutant: "This book is great fun and it's also a surprisingly great way to learn more about the atmosphere and specific of the mid XX century comics industry." "Highly recommended."
Just A Guy That Likes To Read: "While this is the third mystery to feature the widow Maggie Starr and Jack Starr (a private eye of sorts), Seduction of the Innocent reads extremely well as a standalone."
NoirWHALE: "a fast read, hedged by a bevy of hilarious characters and culminating in a delicious ‘whodunit.’"
ComicBuzz: "Collins’s prose is a Chandleresque homage and he sets the tone, setting and location expertly"
Crime Fiction Lover: "[Collins's] knowledge of the comic book world and the period the book is set in allows him to inject a wealth of historical fact into the narrative…[with] enough thrills here to mean that readers can enjoy this book as a PI thriller, even if they are not as interested in the comics angle."
BioGamer Girl: "Seduction of the Innocent is a well-written novel that proves why Collins is the best at what he does."
International House of Geek: "a near-perfect journey of pulp fiction-y goodness"
Atomic Moo: "does a great job of using a little history and lot of imagination to create an engaging mystery."
KVLT KVLTVRE: "Max Allan Collins has an enviable reputation as both a skillful novelist and excellent comic book writer and that shines though in this thoroughly enjoyable and impossible to put down book."
ConSequential: "The writing is zippy and never feels like parody, and captures a bygone age of comics well."
Pulp 300: "definitely worth reading. And owning. HCC just does books right."
My Big Honkin Blog: "you’ll be looking for a firm handhold as the story takes on breakneck pace. The magic is in the mystery and the hunt for answers.:
October Country: "a solid murder mystery and a fascinating peek into one of the most controversial and misguided smear campaigns in American history." "another win for Hard Case Crime"
Bibliodiscoteque: "Seduction of the Innocent is an absolute must-read for a fan of comic history, wise-cracking investigators, and fans of historical fiction."
ComicAttack: “With great characters, witty prose, and a mystery that legitimately keeps you guessing, Seduction of the Innocent is a fun read from start to finish.”
Crime and Thriller Fiction Shots Magazine: "Seduction of the Innocent is a well-written classic sexy pulp novel that should be read even if it is just to get the low down on what was happening to comics during that era. A truly brilliant read."
Comics Can Be Murder: “Thumbs up.”
Nerdbloggers: “a familiar tale that still seems surprisingly fresh. I couldn't possibly recommend the book more to fans of the genre or classic comics.”
Frank the Movie Watcher: “so good I just couldn't put it down.”